Most Courageous Player (as voted by teammates)
2023- Breece Hall, Running Back
2022- Vinny Curry, Defensive Lineman
2021- Ashtyn Davis, Safety
2020- Ryan Griffin, Tight End
2019- Bilal Powell, Running Back
2018- Quincy Enunwa, Wide Receiver
2017- Lawrence Thomas, Fullback
2016- Muhammad Wilkerson, Defensive Lineman
2015- Ryan Fitzpatrick, Quarterback
2014- Rontez Miles, Safety
2013- Isaiah Trufant, Cornerback
2012- Jeff Cumberland, Tight End
2011- Brandon Moore, Guard
2010- Shaun Ellis, Defensive End
2009- David Harris, Linebacker
2008- Jerricho Cotchery, Wide Receiver
2007- Laveranues Coles, Wide Receiver
2006- Chris Baker, Tight End
2005- Wayne Chrebet, Wide Receiver
2004- Chad Pennington, Quarterback
2003- Dave Szott, Guard
2002- Vinny Testaverde, Quarterback
2001- Curtis Martin, Running Back
2000- Jason Fabini, Tackle
1999- Marvin Jones, Linebacker
1998- Pepper Johnson, Linebacker
1997- David Williams, Tackle
1996- Siupeli Malamala, Guard-Tackle
1995- Kyle Clifton, Linebacker
1994- Jim Sweeney, Center
1993- Lonnie Young, Free Safety
1992- Dale Dawkins, Wide Receiver
1991- Paul Frase, Defensive Tackle-End
1990- Freeman McNeil, Running Back
1989- Ken O'Brien, Quarterback
1988- Tom Baldwin, Defensive Tackle
1987- Joe Klecko, Defensive Tackle-End
1986- Dan Alexander, Guard
1985- Johnny Lynn, Cornerback-Safety
1984- Joe Fields, Center